Funny Face – Delightful!

The plot of George and Ira Gershwins’ 1927 show Funny Face bears no resemblance to that of the subsequent Fred Astaire/Audrey Hepburn film which centered on the sophisticated world of fashion. Originally, the musical was (and is) a romantic comedy featuring: Jimmy Reeve ( Patrick Graver) a young, wealthy man and his three attractive wards – Frankie (Jessica Ernest)- a ditsy blonde who congenitally lies, June (Whitney Winfield)- a sweet young woman impatiently waiting for Jimmy to propose, and Dora (Caitlin Wilayto), a comedienne type aggressively searching for a husband, the guardian’s best friend- Dugsie (Blake Spellacy), Peter (Seth Danner)- a handsome aviator who get caught up in misrepresented robbery, two bungling burglars (Herbert-Edward Tolve and Chester- Bill Bateman), impersonations, and a company of dancing/singing flappers with jaunty swains.

Caitlin Wilayto, Patrick Graver, Whitney Winfield

Producer and Creator of Musicals Tonight, Mel Miller, and his cohorts have put together a buoyant version of the piece helmed by Director/Choreographer Casey Colgan of whom I am now a serious fan. Having been loyal to this organization for a great many years, I’ve watched valuable presentations of rarely revived musicals get better and better, despite short rehearsal time, minimal trappings, and shoestring budget. With this production, the organization has reached a new high.

Opening at Jimmy Reeve’s birthday party, we see a line of long-limbed chorus girls who not only dance up a storm but kick like Rockettes. Watch that fringe fly! The boys are equally swell, not only partnering, but at one point ebulliently executing acrobatics. We’re treated to Charlestons, Waltzes, and Tap. Everyone is cute without being saccharine. This is a cohesive company accurately representing a period show while having an infectiously good time.

Seth Danner, Blake Spellacy

Songs like “Funny Face,” “S’Wonderful,” “He Loves and She Loves,” and “How Long Has This Been Going On?” are just a of few of the iconic numbers here. Vocal arrangement is excellent. Choreography is lively, attractive, fresh and perfectly suited to the small stage. I wish I could tell you to immediately secure tickets, but unfortunately I saw the piece at the end of its run. This review is partly for the record, partly to acknowledge fine work, and partly to make you more aware of the blooming Musicals Tonight.

two-couples

Caitlin Wilayto and Blake Spellacy; Jessica Ernest and Seth Danner

Patrick Graver and Jessica Ernest as Jimmy and Frankie are dancers in song and dance roles. Both entertain tilting towards the former at which they’re thoroughly appealing. Ernest emulates her dizzy character with modest brio.

Caitlin Wilayto (Dora) and Whitney Winfield (June) are well cast. Wilayto has good comic timing and manages to be engagingly quirky without veering towards trite. Winfield has a superb voice and genuine presence.

couple

Whitney Winfield and Patrick Graver

Seth Danner (Peter) and Blake Spellacy (Dugsie) are both skilled male ingénues. They sing, dance, and relate with natural charm. Spellacy reminds me of song and dance man Gene Nelson (check out such as the film Oklahoma!) – a high compliment.

As Maladroit burglars, Edward Tolve and Bill Bateman – the former especially – are amusing in their roles and excel at “The Babbitt and The Bromide.” Though the nifty vaudeville number has nothing to do with this story, it’s a hoot. Relevance might be easily supplied by a line or two of dialogue indicating the burglars are hiding from cops by substituting for the resort’s headliners.

Also featuring Doug Jabara who comically does what he can as the Sergeant.

Costumes. Wigs, and footwear, apparently acquired and ostensibly overseen by Casey Colgan are flat out terrific, especially the colorful, plaid suits for The Babbitt and The Bromide which it pains me not to be able to show you.

Bravo Resident Casting Director Holly Buczek.

Photos by Michael Portantiere
Opening Left to Right: Christian Brown, Kacie Burns, Caleb Dicke, Giulia Dunes, Kyle White, Briana Fallon, Parker Krug, Andrea Weinzierl

Musicals Tonight presents
Funny Face
Music by George Gershwin; Lyrics by Ira Gershwin
Libretto- Fred Thompson & Paul Gerard Smith
Directed and Choreographed by Casey Colgan
Music Director/Vocal Arranger-James Stenborg
The Lion Theatre
410 West 42nd Street
NEXT: The world premiere of Hoi Polloi by Noel Coward-November 1-13
Musicals Tonight website

Share This Post:

Bluesky Icon Bluesky
Facebook

Internationally acclaimed American tenor Brian Jagde is enjoying a glorious 2025-26 operatic season that includes a few firsts. After overcoming an arduous health challenge, he opened the season for Teatro Real in Madrid with his…

Great time to introduce a child to live theater during Kids’ Night on Broadway!

Music director Leon Botstein led the American Symphony Orchestra (ASO) in a commemorative concert on January 30 at Carnegie Hall to celebrate the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence. The program highlighted the evolution…

On an evening when stepping outside felt like plunging into the core of winter, Carnegie Hall became a sacred refuge for those brave enough to venture outdoors. The mood of the entire evening felt indeed…

There’s great theater this winter in New Jersey. Marina Kennedy lists the shows.

Apartment Approved: Why Urban Women Are Turning to Curated Adoptions for the Perfect City Dog

City life compresses everything. Work, friendships, grocery bags, and ambitions all have to coexist in a few carefully organized rooms. When a dog enters that picture, it becomes a daily presence that shapes sleep, social life, and even rental choices. Scrolling through listings, falling for a photograph, and arranging a visit within hours has started to feel out of step with the realities of apartment living. The new mood is more deliberate. Many women are

read more

5 Modern Architectural Trends For The Great Outdoor Room

The traditional ‘back porch’ is in danger of becoming a memory.  As we march into 2026, the back porch of old has turned into the ‘Great Outdoor Room’ (tah da). Since COVID, people are spending more time at home and really want to create something special in their outdoor spaces, so they LIKE staying at home. These special outdoor living spaces still demand careful material curation and creative architecture, plus some really solid engineering, as

read more

Safety Tips for Women Who Are Active on Social Media, Protecting Personal Information

Social media can be a place to share wins, keep up with friends, build a brand, or simply feel less alone. But it also rewards visibility, and visibility can attract the wrong kind of attention. For women in particular, the risks often include harassment, impersonation, stalking, doxxing, and boundary violations that add up fast. The goal is to stay in control of your privacy, strengthen your online safety, and keep enjoying the internet on your

read more

The Gut-Brain Conversation: Why Mental Clarity Begins in the Microbiome

Some days your brain feels a beat behind. You slept, you ate, you did all the “right” things, and still the fog shows up. Focus slips. Words take longer to land. For years, mental clarity was treated as a matter of discipline: better habits, more willpower. Now the spotlight is on the gut. The microbiome doesn’t just affect digestion. It influences mood, stress response, and how sharp you feel from one day to the next.

read more

Shipping vs. Driving Your Car Across the Country: What Actually Costs More in 2026

There’s a certain romanticism attached to the Great American Road Trip. We’ve all seen the movies open windows, a selected playlist, and the freedom of the highway. But when you’re actually faced with the prospect of moving your life (and your car) from, say, New Jersey to Oregon, that romanticism usually hits a wall of reality by the second day. By hour fifteen of staring at the same gray asphalt, you start doing the math.

read more
You've loaded all available articles in this category

Apartment Approved: Why Urban Women Are Turning to Curated Adoptions for the Perfect City Dog

City life compresses everything. Work, friendships, grocery bags, and ambitions all have to coexist in a few carefully organized rooms. When a dog enters that picture, it becomes a daily presence that shapes sleep, social life, and even rental choices. Scrolling through listings, falling for a photograph, and arranging a visit within hours has started to feel out of step with the realities of apartment living. The new mood is more deliberate. Many women are

read more

5 Modern Architectural Trends For The Great Outdoor Room

The traditional ‘back porch’ is in danger of becoming a memory.  As we march into 2026, the back porch of old has turned into the ‘Great Outdoor Room’ (tah da). Since COVID, people are spending more time at home and really want to create something special in their outdoor spaces, so they LIKE staying at home. These special outdoor living spaces still demand careful material curation and creative architecture, plus some really solid engineering, as

read more

Safety Tips for Women Who Are Active on Social Media, Protecting Personal Information

Social media can be a place to share wins, keep up with friends, build a brand, or simply feel less alone. But it also rewards visibility, and visibility can attract the wrong kind of attention. For women in particular, the risks often include harassment, impersonation, stalking, doxxing, and boundary violations that add up fast. The goal is to stay in control of your privacy, strengthen your online safety, and keep enjoying the internet on your

read more

The Gut-Brain Conversation: Why Mental Clarity Begins in the Microbiome

Some days your brain feels a beat behind. You slept, you ate, you did all the “right” things, and still the fog shows up. Focus slips. Words take longer to land. For years, mental clarity was treated as a matter of discipline: better habits, more willpower. Now the spotlight is on the gut. The microbiome doesn’t just affect digestion. It influences mood, stress response, and how sharp you feel from one day to the next.

read more

Shipping vs. Driving Your Car Across the Country: What Actually Costs More in 2026

There’s a certain romanticism attached to the Great American Road Trip. We’ve all seen the movies open windows, a selected playlist, and the freedom of the highway. But when you’re actually faced with the prospect of moving your life (and your car) from, say, New Jersey to Oregon, that romanticism usually hits a wall of reality by the second day. By hour fifteen of staring at the same gray asphalt, you start doing the math.

read more
You've loaded all available articles in this category