Through middle school, Megan and Allison Hadley were inseparable, sharing the same friends, sports, and hobbies. That changed in high school. Megan was still the good student, while Allison began hanging out with Stephanie Knowles, skipping class to drink and smoke pot. Coming home one afternoon, Megan finds Allison and Stephanie high, trashing the living room.
Megan demands that Stephanie leave while she and Allison take their dog, Jack, for a walk. In the woods behind their home, they run into a young man who asks for their help to find his dog, Bengi. Jack begins to growl, warning Megan the man may not be what he seems. But Allison convinces Megan they should help him.
Jack was right. The man attacks Allison, drugging her by holding a cloth over her face. Megan attempts to escape, but he overpowers her, too. He even drugs Jack. When the girls wake up, they find themselves in separate cages inside a concrete box. They have collars around their necks. When they don’t do what he says, he zaps them with an electric charge.
Megan soon realizes they have been kidnapped by a serial killer of twins, John Lesley Walsh, and she and Allison are his latest victims. When they are not in their cages, one of them is allowed to take a shower and then satisfy his sexual needs in a room with a mattress. They have buckets in their cages to relieve themselves. He changes them regularly. With a diet consisting of protein bars and an occasional peanut butter and jelly sandwich, the women are weak and disoriented. Escaping seems unlikely.

Megan, however, does escape, but doesn’t fulfill her promise to come back for Allison. Twenty years later, Megan is married to Kyle, and they have a daughter, Daisy. As a woman who escaped from Walsh, Megan is in demand as a speaker with a non-profit called Beacon Light, and best friends with the organization’s founder, Zoe. Working with a ghost writer, Jessica Stern, Megan pens a bestselling memoir. She’s now working with a well known actress and filmmaker, Seraphina, on a documentary about her life.
For more than 20 years, Megan had hidden a secret about her escape that will destroy everything has has worked to create. In a vulnerable moment, she confesses to Jess who, facing gambling debts, uses that secret to blackmail Megan. When Jess is found dead, her cabin burned down, Megan knows she might be charged with the murder. Yet another secret that must remain hidden.
Is that secret about the be revealed? Megan finds a black rose on her car with a note that says, “SOON.” And a woman attempts to pick up Daisy from school, a woman who the teachers thought was Megan. Did her twin survive? Is she back to make Megan pay? And why did she wait 20 years to surface?
Avery Bishop tells the story alternating between “before,” when the twins are in captivity, and “now.” The “before” scenes are, in many places, difficult to read. In the “now” scenes we find Megan slowing unraveling as the lies she has told for two decades refuse to stay hidden. And, of course, there are many surprises along the way before Megan gets the answers that will finally set her free.
The Girls in the Dark
Avery Bishop
Top Bigstock photo by Quality Stock Arts
Our editors love to read and independently recommend these books. As an Amazon Affiliate, Woman Around Town may receive a small commission from the sale of any book. Thank you for supporting Woman Around Town.





