The Types of Secondhand Stores in New York City

The sustainability movement has proved to be a boon for shops that offer secondhand goods. But deciding which type of store suits your needs can be tricky. Here is a breakdown of the key differences between thrift stores, charity shops, vintage shops, resale shops, and consignment shops. 

Thrift Stores
These are typically nonprofit and benefit a particular cause or charity. They rely on donations of clothing, furniture, home goods, books, toys, and other items. If you plan to donate, check on when those items are accepted and if there are any restrictions for what might not be accepted. From the website, you can also arrange for donated items to be picked up. Prices in thrift shops are usually very low and sometimes can be negotiated. Items are not curated for value, but smart shoppers may unearth a treasure that could be worth real money. Funds collected go towards the charity’s cause.
One to check out: 
Goodwill New York/New Jersey Store and Donation Center
25 Elm Place
Brooklyn

Charity Shop
Trendier than a traditional thrift store, charity shops present curated items that may be repaired, cleaned, and presented in an appealing manner to encourage shoppers to buy. All proceeds go towards a specific cause. Housing works, for example, focuses on helping people living with HIV/AIDS.
One to check out:
Housing Works Thrift Stores 
Multiple locations including Chelsea, SoHo, and the Upper East Side

Vintage Shops
These outlets are for serious collectors or just someone looking for something that may be old, but will never go out of style. Prices will fluctuate depending upon the age and condition of the item. Love the roaring twenties? Then look for a beaded purse or an art deco necklace. But you don’t have to go that far back to shop vintage. These are stores that specialize in 70s bohemian dresses, 90s band tees, or designer clothing from the houses of Oscar de la Renta or Chanel.
One to check out:
10 ft Single by Stella Dallas
285 N 6th St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
718-486-9487

Resale Shops
These shops are for-profit businesses that buy and resell secondhand goods. They often focus on current or in-demand items like clothing, handbags, and homeware. Price points are mid-range, less expensive than new retail, but higher than thrift. If you have something you’d like to sell, these shops may purchase on the spot for cash or credit.
One to check out:
Buffalo Exchange
East Village and Williamsburg

Consignment Shops
Selling items on behalf of the owner is the focus of consignment shops. They accept brand-name or designer items that are in good condition. Prices will vary depending upon the brand and condition. The owner gets paid only when the item sells. Check to see whether you will need an appointment before visiting with your goods.
One to check out:
Ina
207 West 18th Street

Top photo: Bigstock

Share This Post:

Bluesky Icon Bluesky
Facebook

Easter and Passover are just days away.  Do you have the wines that you want to serve or bring to a gathering?  Whether you are eating a traditional holiday meal or enjoying creative cuisine, we…

You don’t have to be Italian to serve up these delicious foods for your Easter celebration. Head to Bronx Little Italy or arrange a delivery.

The Feast of St. Joseph – or La Festa di San Giuseppe – is celebrated every year on March 19 to honor the earthly father to Jesus. It’s also Italy’s Father’s Day. Plus, if your name is…

Greet the new year with a new you. Got yourself one of these products to help you relax and restore your outer self in the days and weeks to come.

Turn your home into an inviting holiday setting without all the fuss and worry.

Whether shopping for a holiday, a special event, or just to serve with dinner, McCabe’s Wine & Spirits is the place to shop. Marina Kennedy interviews owner and wine expert Daniel Mesznik.

Poet’s Corner – The American Way

About her poem, Robin Clark says, “America is a new America. The future is unknown, but I do feel hope. I do believe in us…it’s just the hoops we are yet to jump through, to return to national decency, which alarms me.”

read more

Considering Ice Baths for Anxiety? A Cautious, Compassionate Overview

Anxiety can make almost any promise of relief feel worth looking into. When stress sits in your chest, your thoughts race, or your body feels stuck on high alert, it makes sense to wonder whether something intense and physical might interrupt that cycle. Some people become curious about ice baths for anxiety because cold exposure is often described as energizing, mood-shifting, or mentally clarifying. That interest is understandable. Still, the research is not strong enough to say

read more

Best Girls’ Night Out Ideas in NYC That Actually Feel Worthwhile

Planning a night out in New York City should feel exciting, but it often ends up being predictable. The same crowded bars, long lines, and overpriced cocktails can quickly turn what should be a fun experience into something forgettable.  When you’re organizing a birthday, a bachelorette party, or simply a long-overdue girls’ night out, expectations are higher. You want energy, connection, and something that actually brings everyone together. That’s why more women are starting to

read more

Why Discerning Women Are Choosing Private Safaris Over Group Travel

There has been a noticeable and profound shift in how women are approaching international travel. When the objective is no longer merely to take a brief vacation, but to step into an environment that feels grounding and genuinely transformative, standard tourism simply falls short. For decades, group travel filled this role because it offered a predictable, structured way to navigate destinations that initially felt unfamiliar or distant. However, expectations have evolved. The rigid structure that

read more
Raynott

Travel Prep for Families: Staying Organized on the Go

Have you ever started a family vacation feeling like you needed a vacation first? Planning a trip with kids can feel like managing a small moving company. Bags multiply. Schedules overlap. Someone always forgets a charger. Popular destinations like Myrtle Beach attract families year-round with beaches, shows, and boardwalk fun, which means crowds and competition for reservations. Add rising travel costs and packed airports, and preparation becomes more important than ever. In this blog, we

read more

Smooth, Shape, Shine: Elevating Your Lip Aesthetic

A soft smile can light up your whole face. It draws people in and leaves a warm mark. But not everyone feels happy with how their lips look. Some feel they are too thin, uneven, or lack shape. The good news is that change can be simple and gentle. With the right care, your lips can look smooth, full, and bright. If you want to learn how to enhance your natural beauty, read on and

read more
You've loaded all available articles in this category

Poet’s Corner – The American Way

About her poem, Robin Clark says, “America is a new America. The future is unknown, but I do feel hope. I do believe in us…it’s just the hoops we are yet to jump through, to return to national decency, which alarms me.”

read more

Considering Ice Baths for Anxiety? A Cautious, Compassionate Overview

Anxiety can make almost any promise of relief feel worth looking into. When stress sits in your chest, your thoughts race, or your body feels stuck on high alert, it makes sense to wonder whether something intense and physical might interrupt that cycle. Some people become curious about ice baths for anxiety because cold exposure is often described as energizing, mood-shifting, or mentally clarifying. That interest is understandable. Still, the research is not strong enough to say

read more

Best Girls’ Night Out Ideas in NYC That Actually Feel Worthwhile

Planning a night out in New York City should feel exciting, but it often ends up being predictable. The same crowded bars, long lines, and overpriced cocktails can quickly turn what should be a fun experience into something forgettable.  When you’re organizing a birthday, a bachelorette party, or simply a long-overdue girls’ night out, expectations are higher. You want energy, connection, and something that actually brings everyone together. That’s why more women are starting to

read more

Why Discerning Women Are Choosing Private Safaris Over Group Travel

There has been a noticeable and profound shift in how women are approaching international travel. When the objective is no longer merely to take a brief vacation, but to step into an environment that feels grounding and genuinely transformative, standard tourism simply falls short. For decades, group travel filled this role because it offered a predictable, structured way to navigate destinations that initially felt unfamiliar or distant. However, expectations have evolved. The rigid structure that

read more
Raynott

Travel Prep for Families: Staying Organized on the Go

Have you ever started a family vacation feeling like you needed a vacation first? Planning a trip with kids can feel like managing a small moving company. Bags multiply. Schedules overlap. Someone always forgets a charger. Popular destinations like Myrtle Beach attract families year-round with beaches, shows, and boardwalk fun, which means crowds and competition for reservations. Add rising travel costs and packed airports, and preparation becomes more important than ever. In this blog, we

read more

Smooth, Shape, Shine: Elevating Your Lip Aesthetic

A soft smile can light up your whole face. It draws people in and leaves a warm mark. But not everyone feels happy with how their lips look. Some feel they are too thin, uneven, or lack shape. The good news is that change can be simple and gentle. With the right care, your lips can look smooth, full, and bright. If you want to learn how to enhance your natural beauty, read on and

read more
You've loaded all available articles in this category